Speculative Reviews of Imaginary Books
Posted by Rosie on Wednesday, 13 of September , 2006 at 9:10 pm
Please write a short review of an imaginary Science Fiction novel.
None of these books exsist but that didn’t stop us from compiling a set of reviews on them. Consider these to be speculative reviews of imaginary books or should that be imaginary reviews of speculative fiction? I hope you enjoy the reviews. I regret to inform you that these books are not commercial available. However in the case of some of these books that might be a good thing.
I had a blast putting this Brain Parade together and it’s going to be a multi parter as I’ve compiled a good whack of these. Enjoy.
Sean Wright:
If you do not read anything else this year, then you MUST read this fantastic tale of love, betrayal, head-tripping, planet-discovering, consciousness-shifting time travel, called Gob Almighty: A Geeks’ Guide To Interstellar Precipitation, Evaporation and Habitual Spitting by Dr Lars Handel.
Beneath the eco-friendly subterranean world that’s a dirty puddle in Bognor Regis’ red-light district, Gob Almighty’s anti-hero Jack Flasher goes berserk whilst fishing for giant crabs on the storm-ridden pier. Confused? You should be. That’s what’s so appealing about Gob Almighty. You see, it’s a cut ‘n’ paste head-trip from the genre-bending master tall-tale teller, Dr Handel, with thousands of redeeming features, clever intellectual insights, and…other stuff that I’ve forgotten.
Aha - hold on a minute. I’ve just remembered: It’s a rip-roaring rave of a read, where you’ll not need a whiff of a spliff to become…well, even more confused by this ground-breaking narrative style - the spiral. That’s right, the narrative kinda spirals in on itself until it disappears altogether leaving just you, the main character’s unfinished last words and an entire epic of blank pages. Wordwooze? Not on your nelly! From the powerfully creative mind of the author who gave new meaning to communal herpes, Dr Lars Handel wags a nicotine-stained finger at all the well-worn tropes of sci-fi in a brash honest look at the hidden miracles, loves, and slippery life-force within puddles. I’m recommending this stunning book to every sci-fi fan. Buy it now - Gob Almighty by Dr Lars Handel.
Sean Wright is a writer and illustrator of young adult fiction who’s debut novel for grown ups Jaarfindor Remade is just out now.
Julie E. Czerneda:
Once in a lifetime, a book like this is put in your hands. You know what I mean. The sort of book that has you reading in uncomfortable, bladder-threatening positions because you forget to move. The sort that lingers in your mind years after you’ve read it, that changes how you view the consequences of change. As a reader, you long to quote passages, since every phrase has such meaning to the here and now, but dare not read out of context and spoil it. As a writer, you vacillate between despair at your own work ever being this good and delight at having identified that higher bar to aim at for life.
Julie is a Canadian SF writer and biologist
Titan Wakes, by Ed Bromley, is an audacious novel of first contact in the comparatively near future. Mankind is mining the asteroid belt now that raw materials are so scarce on Earth. The colonization of Titan will facilitate the exploitation the outer solar system. Only this activity has disturbed the unimagined denizens of the deep oceans of Jupiter’s moons, Callisto and Europa. How will the Titan Base Advance Party explain humanity’s problems and ambitions to creatures with no knowledge and certainly no interest in such things? But they can’t just ignore the aliens or ride roughshod over them. These creatures have very different but very advanced technologies including effective means of defence, and if need be, attack. They also have their own philosophies which will just as much of a challenge to some.
There are inevitable echoes of Arthur C Clarke’s 2001 and 2010 as well as more recent space-faring books by the likes of Ken MacLeod and Charles Stross. In his aliens, Bromley shows his influences include HG Wells’s Martians, Eloi and Morlocks as well as John Wyndham’s Chocky and the Midwich Cuckoos. He has the confidence to acknowledge all those who have gone before him without compromising his own unique vision.
This is a convincing future. Bromley blends plausible extrapolation from likely developments already heralded in popular science journalism with in-depth knowledge of the Cassini-Huygens probe and similar missions. Thankfully the pace of the story never flags under this weight of learning. Nor does he ignore problematic political, economic and environment futures in favour of technological rapture. Most importantly, the book never becomes an arid exploration of theoretical debates. From Commander Joshua Jin-York on, the personnel of the Titan Advance Party are real, rounded people whose fate will keep readers turning the pages late into the night.
Juliet McKenna is a Fantasy author who also participates with The Write Fantastic
Suzette Haden Elgin:
Graciola Flowbender’s debut novel The GenderBabel Revelation has appeared with all the usual commotion and the obligatory half dozen pages of complimentary blurbs; that doesn’t keep it from being a dreadful book that qualifies neither as science nor as fiction. Its protagonist, neuroscientist Glaub Haff, has not only discovered in the human brain the actual “language organ” once proposed metaphorically by Noam Chomsky, he has discovered that human males have a totally different language organ from the one in human females. Flowbender doesn’t understand neuroanatomy or cognitive science or linguistics or (in my opinion) human beings of either gender, nor has she felt it necessary to do any research to repair those deficiencies; she’s winging it, all the way from page one to page — finally! — 834. This doorstop of a book has no redeeming features. The writing is wooden, the science is made up out of whole cloth, the characters are indistinguishable chunks of cardboard, the dialogue is stupefying, and the plot is just barely sturdy enough to support a three-page short-short. We can therefore confidently anticipate that it will become a major motion picture. Feh.
Suzette Haden Elgin is a writer and artist who blogs at Ozarque’s Journal
Tony Ballantyne:
This book is beautifully written. The descriptive passages bear a rare lyricism; the characters are well realised and believable and brought to life by crackling dialogue.
What the book is lacking, however, is Science Fiction. It has SF on the cover in big letters, it is marketed as SF, and yet the only evidence I can find of SF within the covers is yet another hackneyed time-travel/alien-visitors/alternate-history device. Pseudo literature is all very well, but I like some SF in my SF.
Tony Ballantyne is a Science Fiction author
I paticularly enjoyed Suzette’s review. How often do you see a Science Fiction author come up with an imaginary technology and then rubbish it before your very eyes. Brilliant.
If you want to obtain any of these books I’m afraid it’s going to require a trip to Morpheus’ (Neil Gaiman’s Sandman) library of unwritten books. Which is a shame because I wouldn’t mind getting my hands on Titan Wakes but outside of a loan from the Lord of Dreams I don’t know how I’ll get a hold of a copy.
Related posts:
Category: Whimsical Brain Parades, Science Fiction Musings, Science Brain Parades, Reviews, Brain Parades, Science Fiction
Tags:Brain Parades, Reviews, Science Brain Parades, Science Fiction Musings, Whimsical Brain Parades
Subscribe to Comments: RSS






2006-09-14 08:06:57
Arminchair Pruttman
ARYAN TIGER TANK ASTRONAUTS
Released by Dadaenban Books
Review:
In the 1970s, Norman Spinrad parodied the fascist tendencies of the “Military Science Fiction” subgenre, in his Alternate History novel THE IRON DREAM.
Reading Arminchair Pruttman’s debut novel, one might be misled to think this is another satire of fascist, indeed Nazi Fascist tendencies in certain SF. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Pruttman’s interviews and statements clearly indicate that he takes his work entirely seriously.
In ARYAN TIGER TANK ASTRONAUTS German WWII tank commander Erich Kartmann, fighting the Red Army on the Eastern Front, faces certain death on the battlefield. However, American time-traveling commandos snatch him out of 1942 and take him to 2042 AD.
The explanation for this rather convoluted action goes as follows: The Earth is being invaded by hordes of carnivorous aliens, who are spreading from their base in Russia across Europe. The American command is too enfeebled by decades of political correctness, and female officers have infiltrated the forces, rendering them ineffective against the invaders.
So the American army must enlist blond, blue-eyed and super-competent Oberstumbahnfuhrer Kartmann to lead the tank batallions of the future, on the new Eastern Front, against the alien hordes.
To make a bad story a short one: Kartmann wins, against ludicrously impossible odds. When I had finished the book, I was puzzled by one little detail. The Nazis lost the war. The Soviets clobbered them on the Eastern Front and turned the tide in WWII. So why would the prime losers be considered so eminently suitable for winning another war?
Shouldn’t the Americans enlist Soviet WWII generals instead?
As you might have guessed, the novel is a thinly disguised love-letter to the German tank commanders of World War II; the plot, flimsy and risible, exists only to paint the Nazis as honorable-but-misunderstood warriors with a “code of honor”.
Notably absent from the plot are any female characters. I shouldn’t insinuate that Pruttman has “issues”… but his extensive, detailed descriptions of the Tiger tanks and how long, hard and shiny their guns are, seem to suggest an almost erotic attachment.
However, the truly most sickening scene of ARYAN TIGER TANK ASTRONAUTS is when Kartmann orders his men to torch a Russian village whose inhabitants are “aliens in human disguise.”
Can you see a pattern here?
According to the book’s reader reviews on Amazon.com, Pruttman already has a legion of devoted fans. One of them writes in his five-star review: “I cann’t wait for teh sequel, GASSING THE ALIEN HORDES. It’ll be awsome to see Kartmann lead his Grey Tigers agin!”
Well, every lost cause has its admirers.
———
2006-09-14 08:59:52
A very “out there” review but yet it sounds so familiar. Excellent.
There isn’t a real world author who might have written this imaginary book is there?
2006-09-14 09:47:31
I am shocked - shocked! - by the suggestion that I’m poking fun at a actual, existing novel. Surely, no publisher worth his salt would print a novel that glorifies Nazis in a science-fiction context?
(*awkward silence, crickets chirping in background*)
2006-09-15 02:21:07
[…] 8 - Speculative Reviews of Imaginary Books | memetherapy “None of these books exist but that didn’t stop us from compiling a set of reviews on them.” Does what it says on the tin…it’s a Meme Therapy joint, y’all. (tags: genre literature authors interviews humour fiction speculative books imaginary reviews bogus) […]